When it comes to training your dog, choosing the right gear can make a world of difference. Whether you’re teaching your puppy to walk calmly by your side or helping your adult dog break a bad habit, the right training tool can ensure that your sessions are safe, comfortable, and effective. At Otis & I, we often hear the question: Should I use a collar or a harness for training my dog? The answer depends on your dog’s needs, their training goals, and your personal preference. Let’s explore the pros and cons of each option to help you make the best choice.

Collars: A Classic Training Tool

Collars are a common choice for many dog owners, offering a simple and stylish way to attach identification tags and leashes. But how do they perform in training?

When to Use a Collar for Training

Basic Commands and Leash Training
Collars can be great for teaching your dog basic commands like sit, stay, and come. They provide a clear point of connection between you and your dog, helping to guide their movements during training sessions. A standard collar is ideal for dogs who are already comfortable on a lead and don’t tend to pull too much.
Quick to Put On and Take Off
Collars are quick and easy to put on, making them a practical choice for short training sessions or those quick trips outside. They are also a good option for dogs who don’t like fussing with gear and prefer a minimalist feel.
Visibility and Identification
Even if a harness is your go-to for training, many dog owners keep a collar on their furry friends at all times. This ensures that their dog always has their identification tags visible, which can be crucial for safety. At Otis & I, our collars are designed to be both stylish and practical, making them perfect for everyday wear.

Browse Otis & I Collars

Pros of Using a Collar:

Lightweight and easy to use
Great for dogs who don’t pull or lunge
Allows for easy attachment of ID tags
Suitable for dogs with shorter coats, where a harness might rub

Cons of Using a Collar:

Not ideal for dogs that pull or have breathing issues
Can put pressure on a dog’s neck if not used properly
Less control for dogs who are easily distracted

Harnesses: For Extra Control and Comfort

Harnesses have become increasingly popular, especially for training young puppies or strong adult dogs. They distribute pressure across your dog’s body instead of concentrating it around the neck, making them a great choice for various training needs.

When to Use a Harness for Training

For Dogs That Pull
If your dog tends to pull on the lead, a harness can help to reduce the strain on their neck and make walks more enjoyable for both of you. Front-clip harnesses are particularly effective for training, as they help guide your dog’s direction, making it easier to teach loose-lead walking.
For Safety and Support
Harnesses provide extra support, making them a better choice for smaller dogs, dogs with delicate necks, or those with respiratory issues. They’re also ideal for older dogs who need a bit of extra help during walks. This added control can give you peace of mind during training sessions.
Training Active or Energetic Dogs
For high-energy dogs that are easily distracted, a harness can give you more control during training. It prevents them from pulling or lunging without causing discomfort, making it easier to keep their attention on you and the task at hand.

Pros of Using a Harness:

Distributes pressure evenly, preventing strain on the neck
Provides better control for larger or stronger dogs
Ideal for teaching loose-lead walking
Reduces the risk of injury for smaller or short-nosed breeds

Cons of Using a Harness:

Takes longer to put on and adjust compared to a collar
Some dogs may take time to adjust to the feeling of a harness
Bulkier than a collar, which might not suit every dog’s preference

Making the Right Choice for Your Dog

So, which one should you choose—collar or harness? The answer depends on your dog's training stage and specific needs. For everyday use, a collar may be sufficient, especially for dogs that are already well-trained and don’t pull on the lead. However, for dogs that are just learning or need more guidance on walks, a harness can provide the control and comfort needed for effective training.

Consider These Factors:

Your Dog’s Breed and Size: Smaller dogs, short-nosed breeds, and those with delicate necks may benefit more from a harness.
Your Dog’s Behaviour: If your dog tends to pull or lunge, a harness can make walks safer and more comfortable.
Training Goals: For basic training, a collar might be all you need. But for more advanced leash training or working on loose-lead walking, a harness could be a better option.

Collar and Harness Together: A Perfect Pairing

For many dog owners, the best solution is to have both! At Otis & I, we offer a range of collars and harnesses that are designed to work beautifully together. This way, you can switch between the two depending on your dog’s needs that day. For a relaxed neighbourhood stroll, a collar might do the trick. But for a training session or an adventurous hike, a harness could be just what you need.

Ready to find the perfect gear for your dog’s training journey?
Whether you choose a collar, a harness, or both, Otis & I is here to help you find the right fit. Our handcrafted, stylish designs ensure that training is not only effective but also a reflection of the unique bond you share with your furry friend.

Explore Products

Collar or Harness: Which is Better for Training Your Dog?